Get FREE Training Workshop from John Crestani
John Crestani has been recognized by Forbes, Business Insider, Entepreneur.com, and dozens of other publications for his success online. More importantly, he’s helped thousands of everyday people from around the world create success for themselves as well.
How do you set up an A/B test in emails?
Setting up an A/B test in email marketing involves planning, creating variations, dividing your audience, testing, and analyzing the results. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to set up an A/B test for your email campaigns:
1. Choose the Element to Test
Decide on one variable you want to test in your email. A/B testing is most effective when you focus on one element at a time to clearly measure its impact. Here are common elements to test:
- Subject Line: Test different ways of phrasing or using urgency, curiosity, personalization, or value.
- Sender Name: Test using the company name vs. a personal name to see which generates better opens.
- Call to Action (CTA): Experiment with different wording, button placement, or colors (e.g., “Buy Now” vs. “Shop Today”).
- Email Copy: Test different tones (e.g., formal vs. casual) or the structure of the message (e.g., long vs. short copy).
- Images/Visuals: Test using product images vs. lifestyle images, or different image placements.
- Email Design: Test the layout (e.g., single-column vs. multi-column format).
- Personalization: Test using personalized content (e.g., using the subscriber’s name) vs. generic content.
Tip: Focus on one element at a time to isolate its effect and ensure accurate results. Testing multiple elements simultaneously can skew the data.
2. Define Your Goal
Clearly outline what you’re hoping to achieve with the A/B test. Common goals include:
- Open Rate: Improving how many people open your emails (e.g., through subject line tests).
- Click-Through Rate (CTR): Optimizing for how many recipients click on links or CTAs within the email.
- Conversion Rate: Maximizing how many recipients complete a desired action (e.g., purchase, sign-up).
This will help you know which metric to focus on when analyzing results.
3. Create Variations
Develop two (or more) variations of the email with one key difference between them. Here’s how you can set this up:
- Version A: This is the control version, which is your baseline email.
- Version B: This is your variant, which includes the change you’re testing (e.g., a different subject line, CTA, or design).
Example:
- Subject Line A: “50% Off Today Only! Don’t Miss Out”
- Subject Line B: “Exclusive 50% Discount Just for You”
Tip: Keep all other elements the same between the two versions to ensure you’re testing only the element you’ve chosen.
4. Segment Your Audience
- Split your email list into two random, evenly distributed groups (Group A and Group B) so that each group receives a different version of the email.
- Ensure that the groups are statistically similar in demographics and behavior, or use your email marketing platform’s features to automatically split test (most platforms will do this for you).
Tip: Aim for a sample size large enough to ensure the test results are statistically significant. Typically, 1,000-5,000 recipients per variation is a good starting point.
5. Send the Emails
Send the two versions to your audience at the same time or within a short window to avoid timing discrepancies affecting your results. Make sure to test under conditions that are as similar as possible, such as sending at the same time of day, on the same day of the week, and with the same frequency.
Tip: Use your email platform’s A/B testing feature to automate this process if available. Many ESPs like Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, and Klaviyo make it easy to set up and manage A/B tests.
6. Monitor and Collect Data
- Track the performance of each version by analyzing key metrics such as open rate, click-through rate (CTR), conversion rate, and bounce rate.
- Depending on your goal, you may also want to monitor metrics like unsubscribes and spam complaints.
Tip: Be patient while the test runs. A/B tests usually require a few days to gather enough data to make a meaningful conclusion.
7. Analyze the Results
Once enough data has been collected, compare the performance of the two variations. Look for statistically significant differences in the metrics you’ve chosen to measure.
- For example, if you tested subject lines, compare the open rates of Version A and Version B to see which one got more opens.
- If you tested CTAs, compare the click-through rates of each version to determine which CTA performed better.
Tip: Use a statistical significance calculator or the built-in analytics tools in your email platform to determine if the results are conclusive or if they happened by chance.
8. Implement the Winning Version
Once the test concludes, implement the winning variation in your future campaigns. If Version B outperforms Version A (e.g., it has a higher open rate or CTR), use that approach in your next email. If the results are inconclusive, you may want to re-test with a different variation or test multiple elements.
Tip: A/B testing is an ongoing process. Keep testing different aspects of your emails and optimizing based on the data you gather.
9. Repeat the Process
A/B testing is not a one-time activity—it’s a continuous process of optimization. Once you’ve completed one test, you can test other elements of your email to continually improve your campaigns.
Tip: A/B testing doesn’t need to be limited to big changes. Small tweaks can lead to incremental improvements over time.
Tools for A/B Testing in Email Marketing:
- Mailchimp: Offers easy-to-use A/B testing features that let you test subject lines, content, send times, and more.
- Klaviyo: A robust ESP with advanced segmentation and A/B testing capabilities for personalized email testing.
- ConvertKit: Provides A/B testing for subject lines and offers data-driven insights to improve email performance.
- ActiveCampaign: Supports A/B testing of emails, landing pages, and automations to optimize customer engagement.
- Campaign Monitor: Offers A/B testing on key elements like subject lines, email content, and visuals.
Conclusion:
Setting up an A/B test in email marketing is an essential practice for optimizing your campaigns and ensuring better performance. By testing one element at a time, tracking relevant metrics, and analyzing the results, you can improve open rates, click-through rates, conversions, and customer engagement. Over time, consistent A/B testi
